A fierce controversy erupted Wednesday after BuzzFeed News published an unsubstantiated dossier containing lurid details on purported intelligence gathered by Russia about President-elect Donald Trump.
Two media outfits — BuzzFeed and CNN — were singled out by Donald Trump who publicly attacked both as purveyors of “fake news” in connection with the report.
CNN was first to report that Trump had been briefed on the existence of a dossier circulating in US political circles, that alleged Russian possessed compromising information about him.
The cable network declined to give details of the unverified allegations, but BuzzFeed took the controversial step of publishing the 35-page dossier in full — complete with salacious references to alleged sex tapes involving Trump and Russian prostitutes.
Several US media published limited descriptions of the report’s contents — while making clear, as did BuzzFeed, that they were unverified, and possibly unverifiable.
But many media outlets and analysts joined Trump in denouncing the decision by BuzzFeed.
“I think it was incredibly irresponsible.” said Dan Kennedy, a journalism professor at Northeastern University.
Kennedy called it “unfortunate” that the actions of one media outfit — BuzzFeed — stood to further erode public trust in media, after a bruising campaign in which news organisations were pilloried by Trump and during which “fake news” became an issue.
One of the largest online news sites, BuzzFeed defended its decision to publish the 35-page document, compiled by a former British intelligence operative hired by other US presidential contenders to do political “opposition research” on Trump last year.
BuzzFeed editor-in-chief Ben Smith said his goal was “to be transparent in our journalism and to share what we have with our readers,” while noting that “the document was in wide circulation at the highest levels of American government and media.”
But Kelly McBride, ethicist at the Poynter Institute, a media education center, said in a blog post that “publishing an entirely unvetted document is a significant departure from the way editors of most significant publications would define the role of reporting.”
Media writers at leading news organisations echoed the criticism of BuzzFeed — a website created in 2006 which has recently stepped up its investigative reporting and global presence.
Washington Post media writer Erik Wemple slammed BuzzFeed’s “ridiculous rationale” for publication.
“It is unverified — meaning that it requires further investigation,” Wemple wrote. “BuzzFeed has started that process and pledges to continue pursuing it. So why post the documents now?”
David Graham of The Atlantic said BuzzFeed “sidestepped a basic principle of journalism.”
The release “unfairly forces a public figure — Trump, in this case — to respond to a set of allegations that might or might not be entirely scurrilous,” Graham wrote.
“The reporter’s job is not to simply dump as much information as possible into the public domain… It is to gather information, sift through it, and determine what is true and what is not.”
“Transparent transmission of misinformation is no more helpful or clarifying than no information at all.”
At a news conference Wednesday, Trump called the dossier’s release “disgraceful,” training his fire intelligence agencies who he suggested may have leaked it — and on the media.
Trump reserved his harshest words for BuzzFeed, a site that uses analytics to understand how news goes viral and drew some 185 million visitors last month.
“As far as BuzzFeed, which is a failing pile of garbage, writing it, I think they’re going to suffer the consequences,” Trump warned.
He also assailed CNN for breaking the initial story, accusing them of “going out of their way to build it up.”
The president-elect then clashed with CNN reporter Jim Acosta, repeatedly denying him a question and eventually telling him: “You are fake news.”
The cable network later pushed back in a statement, saying: “CNN‘s decision to publish carefully sourced reporting about the operations of our government is vastly different than BuzzFeed‘s decision to publish unsubstantiated memos.”
‘Kudos’ to BuzzFeed
Not all the reaction was negative.
Richard Tofel, president of the investigative news organisation ProPublica, welcomed BuzzFeed‘s decision to publish, noting that CNN had earlier reported on the existence of the document without revealing its contents.
“Kudos to @BuzzFeedBen and his team for publishing the dossier. Once CNN story out, citizens should have evidence to consider for themselves,” Tofel tweeted.
Analysts at the blog Lawfare, which follows national security issues, noted that they had also had the document “for a couple of weeks” and chose “not to publish it while the allegations within it remain unproven.”
But the analysts — Benjamin Wittes, Susan Hennessey and Quinta Jurecic of the Brookings Institution — said the dossier was nonetheless an important issue that deserved to be investigated.
“The president and president-elect do not get briefed on material that the intelligence community does not believe to be at least of some credibility,” they wrote.
“While nobody has confirmed any of the allegations, both inside government and in the press, it is clear to us that they are the subject of serious attention.”
Gabonese President Ali Bongo launched a forum Tuesday of political and social groups on resolving a crisis sparked by his re-election last year, but the
On Saturday, March 25, Cîroc Ultra-Premium Vodka unveiled three brand influencers in spectacular fashion to unsuspecting A-listers at the Sky Lounge Restaurant, Lagos. Best-selling author and
Finance: Darden's acquisition of Cheddar's is bad news for smaller restaurants that are looking for a buyout (DRI)
In a note sent out to clients on Tuesday, a team of Morgan Stanley analysts led by John Glass said that the deal is bad
Most Watched VideosView all posts
- The minister of power, works and housing Babatunde Fashola on Friday, received an ultimatum to fix the epileptic power supply in Nigeria. - A civil
- Contrary to reports in some quarters, the EFCC is not negotiating secretly with Diezani but is prepared for the trial in London in June -.The
Editor’s note: Nnamdi Kanu’s incarceration due to his agitation for Biafra has made him a cult figure especially among Igbos who also share the same
- MASSOB has announced the closure of its camps and headwaters - The group said it has forgiven Ralph Uwazuruike - It told the Imo government that
Couples Caught ‘Having Sex’ Side-by-side Against A Wall In A Town Centre
Ooni of Ife, His Imperial Majesty Oba Adeyeye Enitan Ogunwusi Ojaja II and his wife, Olori Wuraola, met with british royalty, Prince Charles and his
Most Read NewsView all posts
A chieftain of the Peoples Democratic Party, PDP, in Delta State, Chief Sunny Onuesoke, yesterday, condemned the steps taken by Police Inspector General Ibrahim Idris
A combination of Examination of Officers and Librarians at Ahmadu Bello University on Monday repudiated claims by the university's Vice-Chancellor, Prof. Ibrahim Garba during his
The statement of result, dated February 3, 2000; was signed by B.B. Mshelthlila and issued by the academic unit within the Office of the Registrar
By Paul Olayemi Four women were confirmed dead and six injured when a bus allegedly conveying members of the Association of Nigeria Conference of Principals of
Finance: Here are the drug companies that would be the most exposed if Trump got his way to negotiate drug prices (IBB)
The GOP's Obamacare replacement plan got pulled from a vote in the House on Friday, and healthcare stocks have been rallying ever since. But when it
Most Watched Movies
Nollywood Wonder offers you this Latest Nigerian Movies 2016 Full Movie about A wife who is starved of sex, she started cheating on her husband
Nigerian movies. Nigerian movies are known to be the best of Nigerian movies and this is one of the Nigerian movies you would love. This Nigerian
How crazy a man can get by killing his best friend for his mistress.. watch as the story unfolds! Starring; Rita Dominic, Ashley Nwosu, Patience Ozokwor,